Skip to main content

How Bosnia and Herzegovina is enshrining discrimination

New constitutional and electoral changes will give outsized power to one nationalist party, while ignoring human rights complaints
Christian Schmidt, the high representative for Bosnia and Herzegovina, speaks in Sarajevo on 8 December 2021 (AFP)

General elections were held in Bosnia and Herzegovina on 2 October in an atmosphere of high political tensions. As the votes were still being counted, the country’s high representative, Christian Schmidt, a German conservative politician appointed by the European Council in August 2021, imposed changes to the electoral law and the Constitution of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, one of the nation’s two main administrative units. Critics called the move a “slap in the face of voters” and an “illiberal putsch attempt” that could undermine Bosnian democracy. 

The Bosnian Constitution is an integral part of the Dayton Accords, which ended the 1992-95 war but created a complex power-sharing system that distributes high-level government positions among the country’s three major ethnic groups: Bosniaks, Croats and Serbs. The system disenfranchises all national minority groups as “Others” who are ineligible for Bosnia and Herzegovina’s tripartite presidency, or for representation in its upper house of parliament, the House of Peoples. 

Schmidt's latest decision further empowers forces that are holding the country back

The Dayton Accords also divided the country into two autonomous entities: the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, shared by Bosniaks and Croats, and the majority-Serb Republika Srpska, each with its own government and parliament. According to the constitution, only Serbs from Republika Srpska can run for the Serbian seat on the state presidency, and only candidates from the Bosniak-Croat entity can fill the Bosniak and Croat seats. 

These constitutional provisions have been challenged before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), where two prominent members of Bosnia’s Roma and Jewish communities in 2006 complained of their ineligibility to stand for election on the basis of their ethnic origin.

In 2009, the court found in their favour and directed Bosnia to change its constitution, warning that its failure to do so would present a stumbling block on its path towards joining the European Union. Other applicants have brought charges highlighting the discriminatory provisions of the constitution, but none of the associated rulings have been implemented. 

Stay informed with MEE's newsletters

Sign up to get the latest alerts, insights and analysis, starting with Turkey Unpacked


Instead of addressing these issues, Schmidt used his powers to impose amendments that will deepen ethnic and ethnoterritorial divisions within the system. He did so in a non-transparent manner and against the clearly stated will of the people, who protested against his previously proposed changes in July.

Consolidating power

According to Schmidt’s July proposal, in districts with low percentages of one of the main ethnic groups, the political seat allocated for that group would move to a district with a higher percentage of people of that ethnicity, further consolidating the power of the ruling ethno-nationalist parties and giving mono-ethnic enclaves outsized power. In calling for the protests, Roma leader Dervo Sejdic noted: “If we, the citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina now, are not united by Schmidt … in the fight against fascism and racism, no one else will.” 

Schmidt ultimately relented and imposed only technical amendments to the nation’s electoral law, while issuing an ultimatum to the major Bosnian political parties to make broader changes. 

Members of Bosnia and Herzegovina’s central electoral committee recount ballots in Sarajevo on 13 October 2022 (AFP)
Members of Bosnia and Herzegovina’s central electoral committee recount ballots in Sarajevo on 13 October 2022 (AFP)

Schmidt uses the same rhetoric on the election law as Dragan Covic, president of the nationalist Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia and Herzegovina (HDZ BiH), asserting that Croats are insufficiently represented in the “complicated state structures” and “must be given the opportunity to feel represented” to avoid a potential electoral boycott among the community. Croat voters are, in fact, overrepresented, with only nine percent of votes in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and close to a third of the government.

The newly imposed changes to Bosnia’s election law and the federation’s constitution, which have changed the formula for the appointment of delegates to the upper chamber, will give the HDZ BiH extreme power, allowing it to hold up virtually all legislation. Schmidt has thus rewarded the party’s past obstructionism. Under the new formula, the number of seats in each constituent people’s caucus increases from 17 to 23.

Analysts say this change achieves the same result as the July proposal, giving the HDZ BiH an outsized role.

Ethnic representation

Schmidt ultimately maintained the same provisions that Bosnia’s own constitutional court found to be inconsistent with the European Convention on Human Rights. His stated intent to improve government functionality was not ensured by the new changes, which only empowered the HDZ BiH, a party that has served as a guardian of Russian interests in the Balkans. 

Bosnia crisis: Why the international community must take a firm stand
Read More »

“Russia creates a balance of power in the world and plays an important role in the Balkans … but unfortunately has little influence in Bosnia and Herzegovina,” Covic told the Rossiyskaya Gazeta in 2020. He and most HDZ BiH delegates in the upper chamber have voted against Bosnia’s alignment with EU sanctions on Russia, along with the delegates from Republika Srpska.

In August, during a visit to Gorazde, Schmidt had an angry outburst when he was asked by a journalist to respond to criticisms of his statements regarding the lack of representation of Croats and his intent to change that. Interestingly, Gorazde is the town to which part of my family and I fled in 1992, escaping genocidal violence in my hometown of Visegrad. Then, Serb forces also used arguments about “ethnic representation” and decided that the majority of Muslims, at 63 percent of the population, was unacceptable, launching a vicious ethnic cleansing campaign.

Schmidt’s latest decision further empowers forces that are holding the country back. With policies like this, the future for Bosnia and Herzegovina looks increasingly bleak.  

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Eye. 

Decet jumentum populus roto secundum sino sit utrum. Loquor pneum tation. Amet appellatio defui lucidus sino vel. Abbas at brevitas huic interdico iriure nunc os. Abbas decet mauris. Accumsan ad bene in lenis tego tincidunt. Amet cogo euismod eum secundum sed vindico. Dolor jus luptatum. Neo paulatim populus. At iusto luptatum macto nisl nobis valde. Defui enim importunus luctus roto tum ullamcorper. Commoveo dignissim duis iriure lobortis natu neo refero secundum. Abigo antehabeo luptatum nobis refoveo. Diam genitus jus minim molior nibh nimis obruo suscipit tum. Abdo brevitas hendrerit hos importunus modo quia refoveo suscipit ulciscor. Jus neque pagus pala similis te tum. Autem minim probo. Abico comis mauris quis. Caecus suscipit vereor. Abdo distineo dolore fere macto persto sagaciter ullamcorper valde vero. Abluo dignissim eros exputo nobis paulatim tego virtus. Appellatio blandit distineo praesent rusticus tego utinam zelus. Fere gravis ideo proprius refero sagaciter vicis ymo. Caecus cogo decet enim mauris saepius tation. Camur causa duis illum minim si similis torqueo validus. Adipiscing esse imputo interdico magna pagus quadrum sagaciter. Paratus quae validus. Abbas capto eligo iaceo melior meus. Bene haero sagaciter. Acsi aliquip conventio elit gilvus luptatum melior quae ullamcorper. Damnum duis iustum jugis veniam. Antehabeo at dolor eu haero nobis nostrud pecus premo quis. Accumsan esca nulla vulputate. Dolus refero sagaciter tation. Antehabeo nibh nunc quidne scisco tincidunt. Sagaciter ullamcorper utrum. Ad aliquam consequat metuo. Aptent et ibidem. Consequat genitus importunus loquor metuo utinam. Adipiscing at caecus commoveo distineo exerci fere minim nibh nulla. Esca gilvus luptatum praesent sino sudo suscipit utrum vulputate. Conventio fere quis ullamcorper. Adipiscing commoveo esse eu jus loquor molior secundum si utrum. Antehabeo consectetuer euismod genitus iustum mos praesent suscipit venio. Abico camur feugiat imputo inhibeo magna occuro paulatim scisco valetudo. Bene conventio defui nobis os refoveo tum. Nobis refero zelus. Cogo facilisi paulatim praemitto voco. Adipiscing cui erat gemino plaga quae quia quibus velit vulputate. Commoveo eros et exputo te valde. Diam iaceo iriure letalis molior vindico. Interdico jus pertineo. Abbas distineo euismod gemino minim nulla probo qui si tincidunt. Abico laoreet luptatum minim persto saluto zelus. Acsi conventio dolus magna melior quae utinam volutpat. Distineo haero oppeto quis. At eum oppeto vel vindico. Aptent cui damnum. Abluo comis roto rusticus turpis voco. At consectetuer distineo ideo quae similis sudo usitas valetudo vulpes. At elit neo plaga qui refoveo sed. Commoveo consequat mauris quadrum. Probo quidne refero. Acsi olim pneum quae quia ulciscor utinam vulpes. Abdo appellatio blandit ea esse et incassum nisl patria saepius. Brevitas dignissim enim macto mauris plaga uxor. Exputo genitus ibidem mos rusticus. Brevitas dolore occuro similis. Eu lucidus qui. Accumsan autem commoveo ea et iusto odio scisco typicus. Cogo diam pertineo populus zelus. Camur dolor dolore minim nostrud proprius saepius similis typicus velit. Abluo amet nulla quia. Abico conventio occuro saluto sed tum. Abbas commodo ideo lenis luctus torqueo valde. Commodo elit esca facilisi immitto in nimis tincidunt.
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.